Kill the energy
NATURAL GAS: turn the thermostat dial to PILOT, then close the gas shutoff valve on the supply line. PROPANE: same, plus close the service valve on the propane tank itself. ELECTRIC: flip the breaker for the heater OFF and verify dead with a non-contact voltage tester at the junction box. No power, no gas, no exceptions.
Duration: 10 min
Shut water and drain the tank
Close the cold-water shutoff on top of the tank. Hook a garden hose to the bottom drain valve and route it outside or to a floor drain. Open the TPR valve and a hot tap upstairs to break the vacuum, then open the drain valve. A 50-gal tank takes 30-45 minutes.
Duration: 50 min
Disconnect everything
Unthread the hot and cold water lines. Unthread the TPR discharge pipe. GAS/PROPANE: disconnect the flex gas connector and cap the gas line immediately. ELECTRIC: open the junction box on top and disconnect the wiring whip. GAS/PROPANE: pull the vent pipe off the draft hood.
Duration: 30 min
Haul out the old, set the new
Strap the old tank to the appliance dolly and haul it out — it's 150+ lbs even drained. Set the drain pan in place, stand the new tank in the pan, and level it with shims. Anchor two earthquake straps around the tank (top third and bottom third) into wall studs.
Duration: 30 min
Connect the water side
Thread dielectric unions onto the tank nipples (prevents galvanic corrosion), then the flexible supply lines. Mount the expansion tank on the cold-water line with its bracket — it must be supported, not hanging by the pipe. Run the TPR discharge pipe down to within 6 inches of the floor.
Duration: 40 min
Connect the fuel
NATURAL GAS / PROPANE: install a NEW flexible gas connector — never reuse the old one. PROPANE: the burner orifice is different from natural gas — the unit must be factory LP-rated or have the manufacturer-approved LP conversion kit installed, or it will soot up and burn wrong. Gas-rated PTFE tape plus pipe dope on male threads. Reconnect the vent pipe to the draft hood. Then leak-test EVERY gas joint with soapy water: bubbles mean a leak, shut the gas off and redo the joint. ELECTRIC: reconnect the whip in the junction box, matching wire colors, wirenuts tight.
Duration: 35 min
Fill BEFORE you power it
Open the cold supply valve. Open a hot tap upstairs and let it run until the flow is steady with zero sputtering — that means the tank is full and all air is out. ELECTRIC: turning on power to a dry tank burns out both elements in under a minute. Do not skip this.
Duration: 20 min
Light it and test
GAS/PROPANE: relight the pilot following the instructions on the tank door, then set the thermostat to 120 F. PROPANE: open the tank service valve slowly. ELECTRIC: flip the breaker back on. Go joint by joint with a dry paper towel — any moisture is a leak. Watch the TPR valve for the first heat cycle.
Duration: 30 min
Final checks and cleanup
Run hot water at the nearest tap and confirm ~120 F. Recheck every joint after one full hour of operation. GAS/PROPANE: never test draft or leaks with an open flame. Check every gas joint with a combustible gas detector, then confirm the vent is drafting with a smoke pencil or a strip of tissue at the draft hood — the smoke should pull inward. Confirm the home's carbon monoxide alarm works before the first heat cycle and again after it. Haul the old tank to a scrap yard or schedule haul-away.
Duration: 25 min
If the gas line needs rerouting, the vent is damaged or undersized, the electrical panel needs a new breaker run, the install location moves, or you're converting fuel types beyond a manufacturer-approved orifice kit — those are pro jobs. Many AZ cities also require a permit for water heater replacement, so check local code first.
AyX — Accuracy Yields Xcellence.