Fix a Leaky or Sagging Gutter
Category: Exterior ·
Difficulty: Beginner ·
Time: 1.9h ·
Estimated cost: $30
Tools needed
- Ladder
- Garden hose
- Drill/driver
- Putty knife
- Bucket
- Work gloves
Materials needed
- Gutter sealant (for seams and end caps) (1 tube)
- Hidden gutter hangers with screws (6-pack) (1 pk)
- Gutter screws / replacement spike screws (1 pk)
Execution steps
Find the leak with a hose
Dry gutters hide their leaks. Run a hose into the gutter and watch from the ground: drips at a seam, an end cap, or a corner tell you exactly which joint failed. A gutter that holds a puddle after the hose stops is a slope problem, not a leak.
Duration: 15 min
Clean the bad section down to bare metal
Scoop the muck out, then scrub the inside of the joint with the putty knife and a rag until it's clean and dry. Sealant over wet leaf sludge seals the sludge in and lets go by the next storm.
Duration: 20 min
Reseal seams and end caps from the inside
Run gutter sealant along the inside of the leaking seam or end cap and smooth it into the joint with a gloved finger. Sealing from the inside puts the seal under the water, where it belongs — smearing it on the outside just hides the leak while it keeps rotting the fascia.
Duration: 15 min
Fix the sag: check slope, then add hangers
A gutter should slope about 1/4 inch down for every 10 feet toward the downspout. Where it sags and ponds, the hangers have let go or were spaced too far apart. Drive new hidden hangers into the fascia — into the rafter tails where you can find them — every 2 feet through the sagging stretch, lifting the gutter back to its slope line as you go.
Duration: 40 min
Tighten every loose spike or screw
Old spike-and-ferrule hangers pull out of the fascia over time. Replace loose spikes with long gutter screws that bite fresh wood. A gutter full of monsoon rain is heavy — every loose hanger is sharing its load with the ones next to it.
Duration: 15 min
Flood-test the whole run
Hose the gutter again, harder this time. No drips at the seams, no ponding between hangers, water moving to the downspout and away from the house. Fix what's left now, while the ladder is up.
Duration: 10 min
Safety first
- GOOD — Do this from a ladder set on firm ground, and move the ladder instead of reaching. The gutter is not a handhold — it will not hold your weight and was never meant to.
- GOOD — Wear gloves. Cut gutter metal and old screw tips inside a dirty gutter open hands up fast, and what lives in gutter muck doesn't belong in a cut.
- BAD — Seal the outside of the seam because it's easier to reach. The leak keeps running inside, the fascia rots behind it, and next year's job is a fascia replacement.
- BAD — Add sealant to a sagging gutter without fixing the slope. The puddle sits on your new sealant all season and works it loose — sag first, seal second.
- HOLY SHIT — Set an aluminum ladder under the power drop to the house and one gust or one slip puts the ladder across live service lines. Look up before the ladder goes up, and if the gutter run passes under the drop, that section is a pro's job with a fiberglass ladder and a spotter.
When to hire a pro
If the fascia board behind the gutter is rotted (hangers have nothing solid to bite), the gutter is torn or rusted through, or the run is two stories up over concrete — hire it out. Seamless gutter replacement is also a pro job; it takes a machine, not a parts run.
Back to all DIY Guides ·
AyX Estimator — Take the guess out of construction.
AyX — Accuracy Yields Xcellence.